Friday, March 04, 2011

A professor says most human resources professionals are ill-equipped to carry out value-added workforce planning and transformation.

Addressing a crowd of about 300 financial executives this morning, a professor of human resources soundly denounced the corporate HR profession for being mostly unable to provide analytics that are useful in making workforce decisions that build economic value.
Most companies today spend too little effort on attracting and retaining top strategic talent and too much on satisfying the rest of the employee base, asserted Rutgers University's Richard Beatty, who spoke at a general session during the CFO Rising conference in Orlando. In fact, he claimed that typical human resources activities have no relevance to an organization's success. "HR people try to perpetuate the idea that job satisfaction is critical," Beatty said. "But there is no evidence that engaging employees impacts financial returns."
Beatty based this conclusion on employee surveys done at IBM and other companies that found little relationship between job satisfaction and performance ratings. Not only is employee engagement very expensive, but "how do you know you're not satisfying a lot of people you really wish weren't there?"
To buttress his argument, Beatty presented data from a Gallup survey on the performance of about 4,500 customer service employees at an unnamed major financial firm. The survey results, which were based on customer feedback, showed that the employees who scored in the top quartile had a positive effect on 61 percent of the people they talked to. The next two quartiles registered 40 percent and 27 percent positive responses, respectively, but there were enough neutral responses that the employees' net performance was positive. The lowest quartile, however, scored a net 2 percent negative impact.
"You'd be better off had you paid these people not to come to work," Beatty said. "You'd be a lot better off if you paid them to work for your competitor." The financial firm paid about $30 million in salaries and benefits to the employees in the lowest quartile, whose performance cost the firm as much as $50 million worth of business.
However, Beatty pointed out that this kind of performance variability means there is an opportunity to build a more valuable work force. Usually in such a situation, HR professionals try to figure out what the top performers are doing right, then train the others accordingly. That is faulty thinking, insisted Beatty, who asserted that selection is a more powerful predictor of performance than training. In addition, training may not be the problem - some employees may know what to do, but choose not to do it, opined the professor.
"HR wants to treat most employees the same way, and they spend considerable time trying to defend or fix poor performers, taking on the St. Bernard role," he said. "Low turnover isn't necessarily a good thing. Think about where you might want to disinvest."
Human resources is also behind what Beatty called the "silly" idea that a company should try to be the "employer of choice." If you are the employer of choice, he asked rhetorically, who's going to be applying for your jobs? "Everybody and their dog's brother," he said. "You want people who are excited, enthused, and understand how to contribute to what you do, as opposed to those who simply want to find a good place to hide out."
Beatty said that it is most important to think outside the HR department box when it comes to filling the strategic positions that create the bulk of a company's value. To that end, he suggested that companies might be better off appointing someone from outside the HR department to manage strategic talent. He pointed to Precision Castparts Corp., a $7 billion machine-parts manufacturer, as one company that has bypassed HR in several situations. For one, it reassigned an operations executive who ran a third of the company's 150 plants to take control of scouting for and retaining strategic talent.
Such tactics are warranted because while "the language of organizations is numbers, HR isn't very good at data analytics," Beatty said. "They don't think like business people. Many of them entered human resources because they wanted to help people, which I'm all for, but I'm also for building winning organizations."
It's the CFO's job to make sure that the work of analyzing and, as necessary, reconstituting the work force gets done by someone qualified to do the job, added Beatty, and there has never been more at stake than there is now.
"The labor market is in a position to provide you with better talent than you have ever had," said Beatty, co-author of the new book, The Differentiated Workforce. "If you don't emerge from this market with better talent in the roles that really make a difference, I don't think you're trying."

No comments:

MIT OpenCourseWare: New Courses in Sloan School of Management

Forbes - Management

Forbes - Management

Forbes.com: Compensation News

Mercer Global | Retirement, risk and finance news

Mercer Global | Employee health and benefits news

Deloitte Growth and Transformational Strategies

Deloitte Organizational, Financial and Operational Performance

Deloitte LLP

Monster Employer Updates

The Economist: Finance and economics

Reader's Digest Version » Travel

Reader's Digest Version » Money

Reader's Digest Version » Family

Reader's Digest Version » Home and Garden

Reader's Digest Version » Health

Reader's Digest Version » Food

Discovery News - Human News

Discovery News - History News

Discovery News - Earth News

Discovery News - Space News

Discovery News - Tech News

Views on News from Equitymaster

The Outside view from Equitymaster

MBA Confidential Blog RSS | BNET

Practically Radical Blog RSS | BNET

No-Nonsense Boss Blog RSS | BNET

Profitable Reads Blog RSS | BNET

The Strategist Blog RSS | BNET

Human Factor Blog RSS | BNET

The View from Harvard Business Blog RSS | BNET

Business productivity - Business White Papers, Webcasts and Case Studies | BNET

Entrepreneurs - Business White Papers, Webcasts and Case Studies | BNET

Personal productivity - Business White Papers, Webcasts and Case Studies | BNET

Leadership - Business White Papers, Webcasts and Case Studies | BNET

Management techniques - Business White Papers, Webcasts and Case Studies | BNET

Team Management - Business White Papers, Webcasts and Case Studies | BNET

Strategy - Business White Papers, Webcasts and Case Studies | BNET

The MIX

Inc.com

WSJ.com: About India

WSJ.com: Economy

WSJ.com: Managing in Asia

WSJ.com: Management

War Room

Money Game

Gartner Announcements

Gartner Blog Network

Brand Engagement

Strengths-Based Selection

Strengths-Based Development

Organizational Performance

McKinsey Quarterly

McKinsey Quarterly - Industry Wise

PwC global press releases

Global Best Practices - Best Practices in Action

Harvard [HBR] IdeaCast

HBR.org

SHRM Online: HR News

SHRM Online Employment Laws and Regulations News

SHRM Online Recruiting & Staffing News

SHRM Online Compensation & Benefits News

SHRM Online Diversity News

Business Standard: the strategist

Small Business Advisor Blog RSS | BNET

Organizational Structure - Business White Papers, Webcasts and Case Studies | BNET

Hewitt Associates - Articles & Reports

Hewitt Associates - Legislative Updates

Politics

Economy

Managerial Accounting - Business White Papers, Webcasts and Case Studies | BNET

Investment - Business White Papers, Webcasts and Case Studies | BNET

NYT; Human Resources

iTnews - Finance

Human Resource Executive Online -- ALL

iTnews - Training & Development

iTnews - Strategy

Forbes.com: Manufacturing News

Forbes.com: Most popular stories

Forbes - Markets

Forbes - Business